Tuesday, September 10, 2019

Exposing a Mixed Bag of Truth and Lies over Mauna Kea Telescope, etc.

Meet Alexis and Alyssa, as they share the impact the astronomy industry has made on them personally and professionally, and in the Hawaii Island community.
"Participating in astronomy is my way of connecting to my Hawaiian ancestry and culture. Hawaiians are observational scientists who use the stars and natural phenomena to better understand our world and take care of it." -Alyssa Grace
To learn more about TMT visit https://www.maunakeaandtmt.org
-0:33
Click for more
It looks like you may be having problems playing this video. If so, please try restarting your browser.
Close
6,177 Views
www.maunakeaandtmt.org
The Facts About TMT on Maunakea
Comments
Write a comment...

Most Relevant is selected, so some comments may have been filtered out.
Here's the fourth and final part of #AssociateProjectManager's blog about black holes: Searching for Leviathan. https://www.tmt.org/blog/searching-for-leviathan-part-4
Comments
Write a comment...

During and after the planning/EIS process, TMT met with Native Hawaii cultural practitioners, unions, educational institutions, environmental and sustainability groups, and Ali`i trusts.
Learn more on our website at: https://www.maunakeaandtmt.org/facts-about-tmt/#which-groups
Comments
Write a comment...

#ICYMI Josh Walawender wrote this letter to editor on Civil beat about Hawaii's scientific contributions. Read his full letter below:
https://www.civilbeat.org/…/hawaiis-role-in-science-is-a-b…/
Happy anniversary to one of the shows that inspired so many to go into STEM fields. ๐Ÿ–– #LiveLongAndProsper #StarTrekDay
Comments
Write a comment...

Thanks for your support Earl. Earl writes in his letter to the editor:
I love Hawaii, the Hawaiian people and the multicultural environment.
The Thirty Meter Telescope issue has divided my family and friends.
...
Life is too short. We should not give up the opportunity for education, for wonderment, for positive creativity and for betterment of all people.
Imua Hawaii.
Imua TMT.
Read his full letter here:
https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/…/your-views-for-sept…/
See More
hawaiitribune-herald.com
I read in (the Aug. 27) paper (Big Island history) that 50 years ago a quarry 12,000 feet up Maunakea was dedicated as a registered National Historic Landmark. The adz quarry was used by ancient Hawaiians to obtain basalt from which basic stone implements were hewn. The Rev. Kaipo Kuamoo blessed the...
Comments
Write a comment...

Neil deGrasse Tyson, spoke to Joe Rogan this week on the: The Joe Rogan Experience Podcast in which they spoke about TMT and the current situation. Here's an excerpt of what was discussed:
“You know what we do as astrophysicists. We study the universe, rather passively at that. We sit at the end of a telescope where we wait for light to reach us…What we do is try to understand our place in the universe. All I’m going to say is that if you have power over what happens on that ...mountain and it’s sacred to you, because whatever [Mauna Kea] is, it is something important to you and your sense of your understanding of your place in this world, I can tell you that what we learn as astrophysicists from those mountaintops gives us a deeper understanding of who and what we are in this universe.
“So I would say that whatever is your concept of god — be it the creator of the universe, the spirit energy that pervades all space and time, whatever is your concept — the discoveries of astrophysicists bring you closer to it.”
https://www.khon2.com/…/neil-degrasse-tyson-offers-support…/
See More
About this website
khon2.com
“The natives should have entire say of what happens to the mountain.”
Comments
Write a comment...

  • Elliot Van Wie I didn't fully agree with Neil but my favorite paraphrased quote in the interview was something like: Well, the mountain is sacred to some but it should be known that telescopes are sacred to astronomers and scientists...

    That's totally true; for many
    See More
    1
  • Joe Moran if it get's built, that will be one beautiful instrument!
    2
Congratulations goes out to the Event Horizon Telescope team on winning the Breakthrough Prize (aka the Oscar awards of science)! The technology for this was developed on Maunakea. Congratulations to East Asian Observatory and the Submillimeter Observatory!
From the article:
Despite the prestigiousness of the award — JCMT support scientist Harriet Parsons called it “the Oscars of science prizes” — many of the awardees had no idea they were eligible to win until they were told... Thursday morning that they did.
“What’s unusual is that, because of the decision to award the prize to everyone whose names were on any of the papers about it, only 10 of the 30 Big Island people are even astronomers,” said JCMT deputy director Jessica Dempsey. “Most of them are technicians or engineers from here or all over the world. I think that’s what makes me the proudest, the most important part, that it took all of this incredible ohana to make it work.”
See More
Despite the prestigiousness of the award — JCMT support scientist Harriet Parsons called it “the Oscars of science prizes” — many of the awardees had no idea they were eligible to win until they were told Thursday morning that they did.
About this website
hawaiitribune-herald.com
About 30 scientists and engineers from two Maunakea observatories have won an international award for their involvement in the project that captured the first image of a black hole.
Comments
Write a comment...

  • 'Sumi Takeishi Astronomy is awesome!!! Congrats!!! Can't wait to see what TMT an do on our mauna.. make Hawaii famous!!
    1
  • Nathan Victor Yes to astronomy Yes to tmt
    5
Thanks for your support John, and thanks to all our supporters out there for writing letters, posting about how you support our project, and going to the various sign waving events around the state.
From the letter:
Lee Cataluna wrongfully disparaged the thousands who think deeply, carefully and respectfully about the Thirty Meter Telescope, the mauna and Native Hawaiians, and who have made informed and engaged decisions supporting TMT (“Opinions on TMT issue don’t carry eq...ual weight”, Star-Advertiser, Aug. 21).
Those of us who sincerely care about nature, science, technology and the law — as well as about Native Hawaiian concerns and spirituality — but who are not physically and spiritually on the mauna, have more than sufficient “standing” to support TMT."
Read the full letter below, subscription required:
https://www.staradvertiser.com/…/letter-tmt-supporters-hav…/
See More
About this website
staradvertiser.com
Lee Cataluna wrongfully disparaged the thousands who think deeply,…
Comments
Write a comment...

What input did the community members give during the planning process?
- Do not build on the summit or near the pu‘u (cinder cones), which is the most sacred part of the mauna
- If you build a new telescope, take one down
- Pay a fair lease; not $1 a year...
- Education for children should be a community benefit of the project
- Do everything environmentally right, protect the natural resources
- Ensure local residents are trained for these high-tech jobs
- Follow the rules and processes, take no shortcuts

Learn more about this and other questions on our website: https://www.maunakeaandtmt.org/facts-about-tmt/#what-has-tmt
See More
Comments
Write a comment...

  • Keone Lee Local job training, pay a fair lease. How’s that for a starter?
    Most Relevant is selected, so some replies may have been filtered out.
    • Thirty Meter Telescope Hi Keone thanks for your question, thru the Thinkfund, Akamai workforce initiative, workforce pipeline program, as well as other various programs. TMT has been fostering local job training, and not just in the astronomy field. Some of our recipients arSee More
  • 'Sumi Takeishi TMT, you did everything right.. Our government needs to uphold their end and make law and order rule our mauna. #ImuaTMT. #Law&OrderOnMaunaKea
In this morning's Hawaii Tribune Herald, State Sen. Lorraine Inouye sent a second letter to Gov. David Ige and her legislative colleagues urging them to help find a resolution to the blockade of Maunakea Access Road. Thank you State Sen Inouye for your support.
https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/…/inouye-sends-secon…/…
About this website
hawaiitribune-herald.com
State Sen. Lorraine Inouye fired off a letter to Gov. David Ige and others — her second in a two-week span — urging something be done to end the blockade of Maunakea Access Road by activists protesting the construction of the Thirty Meter Telescope.
Comments
Write a comment...

  • Cole Hea Thank you to both Ige and Inouye for upholding the law in this instance.
  • Ilima Lotu-Kinney Hawaiians and Hawaiians at heart we are the majority. We need to get our ohana registered to vote and next election we will remember the many who spoke out and especially the ones that didn’t. They are OUT! We need politicians who will get to Washington and represent the people of Hawaii. For many this is the only home we have. We can’t and won’t find another.
    3
#ICYMI from our friends over at University of Hawai‘i News:
UH is committed to #Maunakea as a global model that provides inspiration as well as harmonious synergy among culture, education, the environment, and scientific discovery.
-5:13
Click for more
It looks like you may be having problems playing this video. If so, please try restarting your browser.
Close
3,147 Views
University of Hawai‘i News
July 22
UH is committed to #Maunakea as a global model that provides inspiration as well as harmonious synergy among culture, education, the environment, and scientific discovery.
Watch together with friends or with a group
Comments
Write a comment...

  • Laura D Leslie Your mission statement in in contrast to your actions. The students have taken note. No harmony. Who are you trying to convince by this fake post? Other states also are watching and thruout the world.
Most Relevant is selected, so some comments may have been filtered out.
Thank you Wendy for your support. She ends her letter to the editor with:
"It is so very past the time to remove the lawbreaking protesters, open the access road and allow TMT to proceed with building a telescope that will benefit all mankind."
Read more below (subscription required)...
https://www.staradvertiser.com/…/letter-tmt-protests-refle…/

See More
About this website
staradvertiser.com
Forty years ago I came to Hawaii from Oregon and started a business. I…
Comments
Write a comment...

  • Mish Shishido Poorly raised, lacking any culture respect and the lawbreakers are those who forcefully desecrate a place you know nothing about. Take your entitled asses and build this on a mountain you might own, Let’s say, most of the land that America claims to own was actually stolen. I'm sure you can come up with something?!!!
  • Robin Akau Yesterday, I had a chance to visit the Imiloa Astronomy Center, and I have a more accurate view of how TMT will benefit the world atop Mauna Kea. It’s unfortunate the protestors know not what they are standing for. I understand it’s about cultural recognition, but to delay work on something that could change the way we live as humans on this earth is pure selfish ignorance
Thanks for your support Hugo. Hugo recently reached out to us and offered his thoughts and support for TMT:
Hawaii's very existence as a home to us and our predecessors, is the result of reliance on the heavens to guide the Polynesians here, as well as to South America, and the Vikings to North America. Indeed, the Polynesians voyaging to Hawaii, depended on their Kahuna who were learned in “wayfinding” which had astronomy at its core. (An explanation of wayfinding can be fou...nd by Googling Nainoa Thompson a navigator on Hokukea.) The intertwining of the heavens and religion with astronomy exists today and is unquestionable as the resultant Hawaiian lifestyle is tied to the stars, the moon and tides, all involving astronomy as taught by the Kahuna.
So given the above, why do we have a faction opposing a temple of astronomy (The TMT) on the mountain dedicated to exploration of the heavens? We are now at the stage where there is an opportunity for the descendants and successors learned in astronomy, as were the Kahunas, to explore the universe, learning the history of the heavens or exploring worlds possibly viable for voyaging and possible colonization should disasters, natural or man made, make earth untenable. Essentially , the TMT will conduct wayfinding using astronomy as the ancient Kahuna did when they sent their canoes guided by the same heavens to these Hawaiian Islands. It is not in disrespect that this observatory is waiting to be built. To the contrary, it’s a tribute to the astronomers of old who could map the heavens utilizing a handful of sticks. Rather than protesting, there should be a jubilant gathering with prayer offerings to Ke Akua (God) to accept the successors to the Kahuna, the astronomers of today. No matter the culture, we should all join hands and rejoice in the continuation of the voyagers whose knowledge of the heavens is the basis for modern astronomy. Imagine, the same Polynesian wayfinding that guides the Hokulea in its travels today, providing the basis of exploration of the heavens initially described and utilized by the Kahuna 2000 years ago. This common ground should be universally celebrated rather than be used to divide. No doubt, the Kahuna, in their wisdom, would encourage broadening the knowledge of the heavens. - Hugo von Platen Luder
See More
Comments
Write a comment...

  • Euclid A. LoGiudice One side promotes positive, explorative growth while the other side promotes negative, misinformation...I'm happy to be on the side of truth, justice and the universal way!
    5
  • 'Sumi Takeishi Hugo is a highly respected successful business man.. I love being on the side of so many intelligent people... We need to share our mauna. #ImuaTMT
Governor Ige's September Capitol connection newsletter talks about the situation at Maunakea. Read his update, and voice your support for TMT on his facebook page and at the link provided in the comments below.
Governor David Ige
Few issues in recent memory have been more controversial for Hawai‘i than the Thirty Meter Telescope (TMT) project. As people weigh in on all sides, I continue ...to believe that respect for Mauna Kea can be reconciled with astronomy and that Native Hawaiian culture and modern science can work together to benefit the whole community. This edition provides more perspectives on the TMT project and efforts like the ‘Imiloa Astronomy Center, which is setting an example for the future.
Read the September Capitol Connection newsletter: http://ow.ly/CHDZ50vVw4D
Subscribe to the monthly newsletter: http://ow.ly/jqJe50vVw4C
#CapitolConnection#HIGov#HINews
See More
Comments
Write a comment...

In an open letter UH Board of Regents Chair Ben Kudo says he will direct the board to ask the president of the university Hawaii to make the resolution of Maunakea his top priority. He closes his letter with:
"It is said that Maunakea is the piko or the center of Hawaiสปi Island. Let it now be the center for all of us who call Hawaiสปi home. Today, September 2, 2019, is the 181st birthday of beloved Queen Liliสปuokalani. Let us work to find what she called “the heavenly way.” Let us stop the attacks, mischaracterizations, mistruths, and move in a positive direction toward eliminating that line which divides us. Amongst the many voices, many at the university have been silent. For me, that changes today."
Read the rest of the letter below.
UH Board of Regents Chair Ben Kudo made a statement on Maunakea.
hawaii.edu
Board of Regents Chair Benjamin Kudo shares a message regarding Maunakea and the…
Comments
Write a comment...

  • Peter Joseph I’d love for Mr. Kudo to point out an example of where TMT and UH didn’t yield to the community.
  • Martin Zebzda Cooperation
    It’s not my Hawaii or your Hawaii it’s our Hawaii. The protestors need to come together with the Governor and TMT to work out a solution. The Governor is willing to meet; the TMT people are willing to meet: what about the protestors? Does anyone even speak for and bargain for them as a group? If so it’s time for you to step up or go away.
    2
Building Industry Hawaii did a Q&A with VP Squires recently, here's a screen shot from the article. Read the full Q&A on page 24 at the link below:
https://www.tradepublishing.com/…/upl…/2019/08/BI0919_LR.pdf
Comments
Write a comment...

  • Kenneth Kลซkini Wagner Nice Q&A breaking things down a little more. I can’t believe the uranium question was asked๐Ÿ˜ฎ
    3
  • Martin Zebzda I live in Hawaii my family is from Hawaii. The telescope has in no way violated any of our beliefs.
    Global warming, plastic debris in the ocean, overpopulation these do violate our fundamental beliefs. Not a telescope on Mauna Kea.
Thanks for your support Bill, he writes about why Maunakea is the best site for TMT as well as recalling some of the arguments that Keck faced 40 years ago in his letter to the editor in today's Hawaii Tribune-Herald opinions section. Here's an excerpt:
The champions of Arizona or California as the chosen site challenged claims by University of Hawaii and other astronomers for the excellence of Maunakea as an observatory site, despite good evidence to that end. Opponents of M...aunakea claimed insurmountable difficulties with operating at such a high altitude, including huge operating costs, serious health concerns for astronomers and technicians, and violent weather. It was claimed by some that a hurricane passing over the island would lower atmospheric pressure to the point of asphyxiation of observatory staff. And so on.
Most of this was self-serving nonsense, and cooler heads prevailed after the Keck Foundation contributed funding for the observatory, to be named after W.M. Keck. Astronomers — even some of those from competing states — came to see the evident advantages of siting the telescope at a site of unrivaled excellence.
The performance of the Keck telescopes and those to come after them has amply justified the decision to put the world’s largest telescopes at Maunakea, and technical arguments to put them elsewhere now seem silly (although many were probably well-meant at the time)."
Read the full letter here:
https://www.hawaiitribune-herald.com/…/your-views-for-sept…/
See More
hawaiitribune-herald.com
The recent Tribune-Herald article (Aug. 26) on the virtues of La Palma in the Canary Islands as an alternative to Maunakea for siting the Thirty Meter Telescope brings to mind the similar arguments over siting the Keck Observatory nearly 40 years ago.
Comments
Write a comment...

VP Gordon Squires, recently spoke with Star Advertiser about the current situation at the Mauna Kea Access Road. Here's an excerpt from the article:
“This situation that we’re in in Hawaii now is clearly about issues far beyond TMT and Mauna Kea,” he said. Many of the issues the activists raise on the mountain are vast, complex and historical, including Hawaiian sovereignty and self- governance, preservation of Hawaiian language and culture, and environmental protection.
The ...TMT project has become a catalyst for those much bigger issues “to come to the surface and potentially be addressed, hopefully this time successfully,” Squires said. Those issues have now become the focus of community discussions including Hawaiian community leaders, Ige and Kim, he said.
“I don’t see the resolution of the current situation being simply opening that road and reestablishing access to Mauna Kea,” Squires said. “There’s a bigger component that has to be part of this.”
When asked if the larger issues raised by the protesters could possibly be resolved in time to clear the way for TMT, Squires replied that perhaps the prospect of losing a project as important as TMT will help “leadership to emerge and for people to come together to address these fundamental issues.”
“I think this is a situation that has triggered something that is almost unprecedented in Hawaii. I think that’s a fair statement, and so that’s a good thing, and maybe that now gives the impetus for leaders from everywhere to come together and address some things,” Squires said.
Read the full article here, subscription required: https://www.staradvertiser.com/…/arrests-clearing-road-ma…/…
See More
About this website
staradvertiser.com
MAUNA KEA >> The activists blocking construction of the Thirty Meter Telescope project on Mauna Kea are using nonviolent tactics that have successfully spurred social change over the years, but in the last decade law enforcement agencies across the nation have refined their own tactics for containin...
Comments
Write a comment...

We spot some familiar faces. ๐Ÿ˜€
The Astronomy Forum and Fair was held Friday morning at Campus Center at UH Manoa. It featured things like informational displays. And telescopes. There were even talks about celestial navigation, planetary defense, and TMT.
About this website
khon2.com
It featured things like informational displays, and telescopes.
Comments
Write a comment...

  • Martin Zebzda Keep up the good work!
    6
  • Kenneth Kลซkini Wagner I accidentally read the comments on KHON and it was so toxic I had to stop. I’m actually ashamed of being part Hawaiian. I’d rather be recognized as Polynesian and skip the Native Hawaiian part๐Ÿ˜”
    1
Mahalo Kona-Kohala Chamber of Commerce for your support. From the article:
We place our trust in government with an expectation that the rule of law will be enforced. For the existing astronomy industry on Maunakea, normal operations must resume and people must be assured safe access on public roads to their place of work. For the Thirty Meter Telescope, we expect the State of Hawaii and County of Hawaii to provide safe passage for permitted construction to begin.
We must ens...ure the development of TMT and the continuation of the astronomy industry on Maunakea. Losing TMT would be more than the loss of a major Hawaii telescope, it would be the loss of opportunity for Hawaii’s future generations. It’s in the State of Hawaii and County of Hawaii’s best interest to continue to support TMT and the entire astronomy sector in Hawaii.
Hawaii’s astronomy sector provides needed economic diversity with a statewide impact of $167 million. Astronomy activities generate over $52 million in earnings, over $8 million in state taxes and 1,400 jobs statewide. During the construction phase, TMT will create 300 local and specialized construction jobs and once the telescope is complete, employ 140 staff. TMT’s commitment is to fill these positions with as many Hawaii residents as possible and use local businesses for support services.
Read the full letter here in West Hawaii Today:
https://www.westhawaiitoday.com/…/my-turn-kona-kohala-cham…/
See More
westhawaiitoday.com
The Kona-Kohala Chamber of Commerce is a nonprofit organization with over 500 member businesses and organizations in the Kona and…
Comments
Write a comment...

  • Martin Zebzda If you look at the facts there are only upsides to the TMT on the Mauna. There are no arguments against that can be supported by facts. What a fantastic gift to Hawaii. What a fantastic gift to the world. It doesn’t get much better than this. Free the road and let’s get this baby started!
    8
  • Jack Do Mahalo for your public support Kona-Kohala Chamber of Commerce!
    1
The Department of the Attorney General (AG), Department of Hawaiian Home Lands (DHHL), and Department of Transportation (DOT) issued a joint statement regarding the control and jurisdiction of Mauna Kea Access Road. Here's an excerpt from the article:
"HDOT does not permit long-term parking along any of its high-speed facilities. The only other roads in the State of Hawai‘i with the same speed limit as Daniel K. Inouye Highway (formerly Saddle Road) are the H-1 Freeway betwee...n Kapolei and Kunia and the H-3 Freeway between Halawa and the Harano Tunnels, both on O‘ahu.
Mauna Kea Access Road is under the control and jurisdiction of DOT. Pursuant to HRS § 26-19 and HRS Ch. 264, HDOT has control and jurisdiction over all state highways and Mauna Kea Access Road is designated to DOT’s State Highway System as Route 210. This includes any portions of the road that cross over DHHL land
The Department of the Attorney General (AG), Department of Hawaiian Home Lands (DHHL), and Department of Transportation (DOT) issued a joint statement regarding Mauna Kea Access Road.
“State DOT has controlled and maintained Mauna Kea Access Road since it became part of our highways system in 2018,” said DOT Deputy Director Ed Sniffen. “Prior to that time, sections of the road situated on Hawaiian home lands were maintained by the County of Hawai‘i pursuant to a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) between DHHL and the County of Hawai‘i.”"
Read the full article below:
https://bigislandnow.com/…/hdot-attorney-gen-update-status…/
See More
About this website
bigislandnow.com
"The public is reminded that Mauna Kea Access Road is a public road controlled by DOT and that the current blockade is unlawful."
Comments
Write a comment...

  • Susan Rosier What a crock! BS double talk! The just need to work out the payment? Hasn't happened in 24 years !! No payment = No contract = No road paid for! A'ole!
  • Amelia Gora So, jurisdiction belongs to the Hawaiian Kingdom - House of Nobles are to take care of the lands since 1848....Alien creatures claiming jurisdiction when they have No documents of ownership.....HDOT, Attorney General, et.als…..you are on Private Properties of our Royal FSee More
      

No comments:

Post a Comment